About the Author: Originally from Pittsburgh, Harvey J. Graff is Professor Emeritus of English and History at The Ohio State University, USA. He was inaugural Ohio Eminent Scholar in Literacy Studies and founded the university-wide interdisciplinary initiative LiteracyStudies@OSU. One of the world’s authorities, his books are recognized landmarks, from The Literacy Myth to The Legacies of Literacy, The Labyrinths of Literacy, and Literacy Myths, Legacies & Lessons, among others on children and youth, cities, and interdisciplinarity. His autobiography, My Life with Literacy: The Continuing Education of a Historian. The Intersections of the Personal, the Political, the Academic, and Place is forthcoming.
More info From the Publisher: “Searching for Literacy: The Social and Intellectual Origins of Literacy Studies provides a critical account of the development of questions, approaches, methods, and understandings of literacy within and across disciplines and interdisciplines. It provides a critique of literacy studies, including the New Literacy Studies… and completes a series that the author began in the 1970s. [In Searching for Literacy] Graff argues that literacy studies in its academic, institutional, and policy forums – but also in popular parlance – has lost its critical foundations, and this hinders efforts to promote literacy.”
A few years ago, when a very bright and avidly reading eight-year-old friend announced that she had named her new stuffed bear and its cub Bakey and Bearey, I asked her how she spelled the words. Memorably and instructively, she replied, “I don’t worry about spelling.” She shed more light on questions of literacy than she realized.
Searching for Literacy: The Social and Intellectual Origins of Literacy Studies explores the surprisingly broad and complicated underpinning to my friend’s answer to my culturally over-determined question.
In the popular and political imaginary, literacy is a sine qua non of culture and progress, for individuals, societies, nations. It exists in dizzying varieties; there are hundreds of proclaimed literacies. But literacy also resists universal transmission. The reasons commonly given are as many as they are contradictory. They range from individual to institutional and political failings.
Literacy’s place in popular culture is one tellingly ambiguous sign. Corporate capitalism celebrates reading and writing in normative, consumer, and durable terms—for its own benefit. These proclamations are revealingly, though poorly, expressed. Other voices are more mixed.
Today few subjects attract the attention or spark responses as powerful as literacy does. Claims of literacy’s and illiteracy’s presumed consequences surround us. Few pressing issues—whether individual and collective well-being, social welfare and security, and the state of the nation, domestic or foreign—escape association with literacy. Divisive issues of politics, and of race, class, nationality, gender, or geography constantly run up against it.
Despite literacy’s acknowledged importance, its powers on the one hand, and the dangers of its diminution, on the other hand, are taken out of context and exaggerated. Literacy is seldom defined. This adds to the illusion of its efficacy and the underlying confusion
At the same time, we drown in a new era of a seemingly endless flowering of many or multiple literacies. They range from the “‘new’ literacies” of “new media” of visuality, screens, moving and animated images, numbers and symbols, to assertions of literacies, of some kind or other, of every imaginable subject, from aural to emotional, food, sex, culture, and countless others. And we are also told, even less clearly and coherently, that literacy, as we have known it, is irrelevant in the age of post-everything. I have compiled a list of almost five hundred “literacies” that I have seen mentioned in print.
No wonder confusion is rife.
Critical examination reveals a different set of relationships and promotes other understandings. Literacy’s uses and impacts are also aligned with continuities and control. Literacy’s impacts are dialectical and contradictory, seldom simple or unmediated.
Similarly, literacy has at least as often been associated with the life of groups as with the individualistic legacy that dominates our images. On the one hand, we must focus on the collective as well as individual uses of literacy, as people throughout the ages have done in their everyday and more exceptional practices. On the other hand, both the collective and the individual dimensions influence how the other acquires, uses, and are affected by reading and writing. Neither exists alone. Consider schooling or religious or governmental practices, or popular reading culture, or the collective aspects of artistic and scientific endeavors. Simple images quickly give way.
Dominant images emphasize literacy for liberation (which can be quite restrictive) and individual advancement, and less often for collective progress (or conservative reaction). The hugely simplified temporal association of classical Athenian democracy with the incomplete literacy of male citizens is an epochal case in point. However incomplete an association, it stimulated a powerful, indeed determinative influence and set of expectations over the past two millennia.
Among the most important—and least appreciated—critical elements are the absolutely connections among myths and images—historical and contemporary—and expectations, and the ways that they are embedded in and come to undergird attitudes, policies, institutions, and judgments. We need to study literacy and literacies in new ways in their widest living circumstances and relationships, lived and written, experienced and recorded.
It is seemingly easy to study writing and “print.” But it has been so hard to study reading and writing as practiced across media and modes of understanding and expression, especially in their formative and fundamental relationships to conceptions, ideologies, policies, institutions, and expectations.
Searching for Literacy is a hybrid. It is not a complete history of literacy or literacy studies. It is a critical account of the development of interests, approaches, methods, and understandings of literacy within and across fields, disciplines, and interdisciplines with an emphasis on the early modern and modern eras. It is revisionist.
I argue that literacy and literacy studies are historical developments and must be understood in those terms. Those developments have had a profound impact on our traditions of thinking about and understanding literacy and how we study it. Literacy studies, especially in its academic, institutional, and policy forms but also in popular parlance, has lost a sense of its critical foundations. This lack of consciousness hinders, sometimes tragically, recent and contemporary efforts at promoting literacy and developing brave new notions.
This essay is published here courtesy of the author and should not be reprinted without the author’s permission. For more information about Searching for Literacy, visit the publisher’s website.
From the Publisher: "In this “smart, irreverent secret history” (Stewart O’Nan) Sewickley set novel by highly praised Pittsburgh native author Anna Read more
From the Publisher: "In his debut collection of nonfiction, Jim Daniels writes about trees, backyard swing sets, above-ground swimming pools, Read more
New York, NY — The Community of Literary Magazines & Presses (CLMP), the national nonprofit organization that for 58 years Read more
From the Publisher: "Imagine that you are a child who was born in a large family, and during your childhood, Read more
From Mt. Lebanon Magazine by way of Facebook: "On February 18, the Mt. Lebanon Public Library Board of Trustees passed Read more
"The Drue Heinz Literature Prize recognizes and supports writers of short fiction and makes their work available to readers around Read more
"Applications are now open for Read Local Eat Local 2025! This is event is on Saturday, September 6, from 11 Read more
PITTSBURGH, PA – It’s time to book your spot! Registration for the 2025 Greater Pittsburgh Festival of Books is officially Read more
"The Northern Appalachia Review welcomes submissions of poetry, fiction, and nonfiction written about, representing, or engaging with the experience of Read more
But this too is true: stories can save us The writer Tim O’Brien calls storytelling an essential human activity. "The Read more
"'Where do you end and I begin?' is the question which haunts Shaheen Dil’s remarkable memoir-in-poems. Dil’s journey is at Read more
City of Asylum Pittsburgh and International Cities of Refuge Network (ICORN) collaborate to present 30+ free,transformational events over 4 days Read more
From the Publisher: "In 1958, a midwestern family was uprooted from Canton, Ohio to Bukavu in the Belgian Congo during Read more
From the Publisher: "It’s Anny’ s first day of middle school and, after years of being homeschooled, her first day Read more
"A light snow fell on January 30, 2005, a typical cold Pittsburgh winter morning. Inside Calvary, the congregation had gathered Read more
We are so excited to help spread the word about the excellent Woolly Bear Books and Gifts in Carnegie, PA Read more
"If you have considered applying to the CBWR, or have applied in the past and not been selected, this remote, Read more
We're happy to share that Pittsburgh's International Poetry forum is sharing their latest events and performances on YouTube, where you Read more
StoryZ, a Latrobe-based theatre company founded by Artistic Director Dr. Stephen A. Schrum, announces its production of Labor’s Martyr: The Read more
ALL SKATE: True Stories from Middle Life is a series of musings from one mid-life woman, wife, and mother on what Read more
